Applying Polyurethane Perfectly- Foolproof Method for Water and Oil-Based Polyurethane Application

**Heads up: This post contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Meaning I may receive a small commission-- at no cost to you, of course-- were you to make a purchase through any of the links. If I link to a product, I use it, I love it, and I think you would too! Please see my Privacy Policy for more details.

Hi there! Thanks for stopping by the KRay Custom Refinish Blog today as I discuss the many questions surrounding applying polyurethane to wood furniture.

Applying polyurethane perfectly is something that takes a bit of time to master, and depends on a few factors.

Oil vs. water-based being one of the biggest ones. So I’ll begin with an overview of the 2 different types, pros, and cons, etc. Then I’ll show you the best method for applying them both without brush marks & bubbles.

We’ll be talking about applying polyurethane to either natural wood or freshly stained/painted wood. If you’re interested in applying polyurethane over a piece that was previously finished, head over to my post on Repairing Damaged Finishes. I cover polyurethane/varnish, shellac, and lacquer finish repairs.

Although I don’t recommend it, I know some of you may be interested in applying your polyurethane over an existing clear finish.

All I can say is please, please, please make sure you know what the existing finish is before you attempt the following method for applying polyurethane.

Again, you can find info on testing the finish of your piece in my Repairing Damaged Finishes post. Here’s a little infographic from that post to help with that if you’d rather not read the entire post:

Clear Finish Repairs and Identification
Click the image to get a full-size printable version.

If the piece has lacquer on it, you will need to completely remove it before applying varnish or polyurethane. Polyurethane and lacquer are not compatible with one another.

If the piece has oil-based polyurethane on it, you can apply more oil-based polyurethane on top of it.

If the piece has water-based polyurethane on it, you can apply more water-based or oil-based polyurethane over it, as long as the water-based polyurethane has completely cured. (30-60 days)

If the piece has shellac on it, unless you know for sure that it is de-waxed shellac, don’t put polyurethane over it. Pre-mixed shellacs are usually not de-waxed, and not much will stick to wax. You can purchase this:

Applying Polyurethane Perfectly- Foolproof Method for Water and Oil-Based Polyurethane Application 1
$ 0.00
$ 17.99
Gloss Sealer Bulls Eye Shellac Solvent Based Quart

which is a 100% wax free formula. Apply a thin coat over the original shellac and let it dry. Then you can apply oil-based or water-based polyurethane on top of that without issue.

For the best result, start with a freshly sanded & stained/painted piece without any other clear finishes on it.

Be sure to wait the minimum dry time necessary for the particular stain or paint that was applied to the piece. I prefer to wait at least 24-48 hours before applying poly.

If you don’t wait long enough, you might end up pulling off some of the wood stain or paint while you’re applying the polyurethane.

Related: 5 Game-Changing Tips on Sanding Wood Furniture

How To Stain Wood – Your Questions Answered.

Water-Based Poly vs. Oil-Based Poly – Pros and Cons

There are good and bad elements of both water and oil-based polyurethanes. Your final decision really depends on the piece you’re working on: color, size, shape, and where the piece will be– indoors or outdoors.

TypeProsCons
Oil-Based PolyurethaneEasier to Apply.
Slightly more resistant to scratches, moisture, and damages from heat.
Amber cast brings warmth to darker wood colors.
Amber cast may change the coloring of your piece.
Color Darkens over time.
Difficult Clean up.
Longer Dry Time.
Strong Odor.
Water-Based PolyurethaneFast dry time.
Easy soap & water clean-up.
Dries completely clear.
Little to no odor.
Difficult to apply without brush marks.
Less resistant to scratches, moisture, and heat.
Dark colored woods may appear cold and dull.

Not sure which to choose? Let me solve your problem!

Applying Polyurethane Perfectly- Foolproof Method for Water and Oil-Based Polyurethane Application 2
$ 0.00
$ 19.99
ZAR Ultra Max Satin Clear Oil Modified Polyurethane 1 qt.
ProsCons
Waterborne Oil-Modified UrethaneSelf-leveling formula makes it easy to apply without brush marks.
2 Hour Dry Time.
Low-Odor Formula.
Easy Soap & Water Clean Up.
Slight amber tone adds warmth to woods but doesn’t discolor light woods as much as oil-based.
Outstanding wear and durability
None!

First off, I’ve recommended ZAR products before, they truly are the best for wood stains and clear finishes. Their Oil-Modified Urethane is the best of both worlds when it comes to polyurethanes. Fast dry time, low-odor, and easy clean up were enough to sell me on it, but those aren’t even the best thing about this stuff.

It’s incredibly easy to apply without brush marks or bubbles popping up. I don’t even recommend thinning it before application as I will be for the oil-based poly! Definitely check it out, it solves pretty much every problem there is with both other types of poly.

If you’ve landed on this post you most likely already have a poly on hand that isn’t the oil-modified type as it’s not very well known.

So don’t worry! I’m still going to show you exactly how to apply both the water and oil-based polyurethanes for the perfect finish.

If you do have the Oil-Modified Water Based Polyurethane, follow the steps for Water-Based Polyurethane Application.

First up: Oil-Based Polyurethane. Using Water-Based Polyurethane? Skip Ahead to Applying Water-Based Polyurethane Perfectly.

Prep Before Polyurethane Application – What You’ll Need

Applying Polyurethane Perfectly- Foolproof Method for Water and Oil-Based Polyurethane Application 3
$ 0.00
$ 4.27
3M Pro Grade Precision 2-1/2 in. x 4-1/2 in. x 1 in. 120 Grit Fine Block Sanding Sponge

If you’ve reached the polyurethane point of your project, it’s safe to assume that you’ve sanded your wood piece properly, stained or painted it, and it’s ready for the final finish. If not, check out my posts on How to Sand Wood Furniture, Preparing Wood For Staining and How to Stain Wood.

You shouldn’t need sandpaper any rougher than 120 grit once you’ve reached this point. Anything lower would remove stain or paint and definitely sand right through any coats of polyurethane.

You may need to use a sanding block to scuff up the surface before application.

Applying Polyurethane Perfectly- Foolproof Method for Water and Oil-Based Polyurethane Application 4
$ 0.00
$ 6.85
TRIMACO 18 in. x 36 in. Tack Cloth (6-Pack), White

A tack cloth will remove any sanding dust leftover after scuff sanding. You want to remove any dust completely before applying poly. I also use an air compressor to blow any dust out of cracks or crevices. Dust can completely ruin a piece if it’s left on the surface, or if floating dust lands on the poly while it’s wet. So be sure to remove any trace of it beforehand!

Finally, to be sure you’ve cleaned your piece completely, I recommend wiping the entire piece down with a cloth wet with mineral spirits.

Applying Polyurethane Perfectly- Foolproof Method for Water and Oil-Based Polyurethane Application 5
$ 0.00
$ 7.97
Klean-Strip 1 qt. Odorless Mineral Spirits

Skip Ahead to Water-Based Polyurethane Application – What You’ll Need

Oil-Based Polyurethane Application – What You’ll Need

Applying Polyurethane Perfectly- Foolproof Method for Water and Oil-Based Polyurethane Application 6
$ 0.00
$ 19.99
ZAR Matte Clear Oil-Based Polyurethane 1 qt.
Applying Polyurethane Perfectly- Foolproof Method for Water and Oil-Based Polyurethane Application 7
$ 0.00
$ 33.41
NORTHERN WHOLESALE SUPPL 3 in. Badger Fine Finish Natural Bristle Paint Brush
Applying Polyurethane Perfectly- Foolproof Method for Water and Oil-Based Polyurethane Application 8
$ 0.00
$ 8.99
Ampersand Art Steel Wool Set | Michaels
Applying Polyurethane Perfectly- Foolproof Method for Water and Oil-Based Polyurethane Application 5
$ 0.00
$ 7.97
Klean-Strip 1 qt. Odorless Mineral Spirits

Applying Oil-Based Polyurethane Perfectly – Step by Step

First off, wipe your entire wood surface down with mineral spirits.

This will remove any sanding dust, dirt, wax, or anything else that may have ended up on the surface.

Wait until the mineral spirits have totally dried before attempting anything else.

Mineral spirits may feel oily as you apply them to the surface. Don’t worry, it won’t affect the polyurethane finish as long as you wait for the spirits to completely evaporate from the wood. Usually takes no longer than 30 minutes.

While you wait for the wood to dry, create your wiping poly DIY Wiping Poly.

Any brand/strength oil-based polyurethane can be used, but there is one rule to make sure you follow:

Don’t thin semi-gloss or satin polyurethane as they contain flattening agents. According to FineWoodworking, “varnish containing flattening agents should not be thinned beyond what it calls for on the can. The flattening agents will not stay in suspension and white streaky areas may result.” If you want a satin or semi-gloss finish, you’ll need to do a full-strength brushed on, final coat.

Mix it 50/50 with mineral spirits. Stir gently with a stir stick and try not to create too many bubbles throughout the process. Definitely don’t shake. Ever.

Using a lint-free cloth, or old t-shirt, dip into the wiping poly, lightly coating it.

You don’t want the rag to be soaking wet with poly. But enough to apply a very thin coating to your surface. As long as it’s a brand new container, you can lightly press the rag against the side of it to wring some of the poly out. Just be sure everything you do is slow and light, you don’t want to stir up too many bubbles in the poly.

For the first 2 coats, you just want to get the poly on. The best advice I’ve read compared it to a “kid working as a busboy quickly cleaning off a table.

Swirl it on lightly, don’t try to apply it in straight strokes. If you find that you missed a spot, don’t try to fix it. Just cover the table the best you can and then do not touch it. The surface shouldn’t look like it’s soaking wet when you’re finished. You also shouldn’t see a bunch of brush/cloth marks if you’ve done it correctly.

Below is an example of correctly applying the 1st 2 coats of wiping poly.

Wait until the surface is dry to the touch before applying your second coat.

Try lightly touching the surface with your finger. If nothing comes off, you can apply your second coat the same way as your first.

After the first two coats, wait 24-48 hours.

The longer you let it set, the better.

After letting it cure for as long as possible, you can lightly sand the surface with 320 grit sandpaper.

Just lightly sand it until it’s flat, don’t go overboard with sanding. Yes, you’ve applied two coats, but at only half strength. Meaning there’s really only close to 1 full-strength coat on the surface at this point.

Remove all sanding dust, then apply 2 more coats exactly the same as the first 2.

Same way as before, lightly swirl it on.

After these 2 coats, again, lightly sand the surface with 320 grit sandpaper.

If there are any serious flaws or cloth marks, you can lubricate the 320 wet-dry sandpaper with water and lightly sand the surface.

We’ve now completed 4 light coats of wiping poly, amounting to 2 full coats of regular polyurethane.

For some pieces, this is enough protection. But I’d recommend at least 1 more full coat for even the pieces used less frequently.

For the next coats, you’ll need to mix up a new Polyurethane: Mineral Spirits Ratio, 5:1.

4 parts Polyurethane to 1 Part Mineral Spirits. The 5:1 ratio leaves a bit thicker of a coat, for more protection, but still flows easier than full strength polyurethane.

You should also use a paintbrush for these coats as well. That Natural Bristle paintbrush I recommended earlier– you were wondering when that would come into play, right?

Starting with a clean brush, dip into your thinned poly mixture.

Coat the brush, then let it hang over the container for a bit and drop off some of the excesses. Try not to touch the brush to the sides of the container at all as that may introduce bubbles or dried poly that has settled on the edge.

Once it has stopped dripping, bring the brush to the center edge of your surface and drag it to the edge.

Slowly and lightly dragging the brush across the surface.

Next. moving the opposite direction, start a little to the right of where you started the first stroke. Drag the brush back to the opposite edge of the surface.

So your first stroke moves to the right side of the surface. The second stroke moves toward the left side of the surface.

Dip the brush into the poly again, let drip, and repeat.

Starting in the middle of the surface directly below your first line, slightly overlapping it by 1/2″ or so. Move toward the right, then back to the center, then to the left.

If that confuses you this video may help:

Once you’ve covered the entire surface, don’t dip your brush again. Use the dry brush to “feather” the entire surface.

Lightly drag the tip of the brush down each line from left to right. You don’t want to apply much pressure at all. Just softly scrape to spread out any puddling or bubbles. One time for each line and nothing more!

Then leave it alone for 24 hours.

Do not try to fix any spots with brush marks or bubbles. Just go clean your brush with mineral spirits and leave the area for 24 hours.

After 24 hours, sand with 320 wetdry sandpaper.

For serious brush marks or bumps, wet sand with a little bit of water and a drop of dish detergent. Use a sanding block, not a power anything.

Once you’ve got it as smooth as possible, spray and wipe down the surface until it is completely dust-free. Then leave the area.

Don’t return to the work area or have anyone else around the work area for at least 2 hours. This will help keep the area completely dust-free.

You’re on to the final, final coat now. So take a bit more care in everything you do for this one if you want it to truly come out perfectly. NO DUST!

Using the same mixture you used for the last coat, roughly 5:1, you’re going to wipe on this final coat with a rag.

Make sure you keep a couple of extra rags nearby also, you will need a dry rag and the rag you use to apply the poly. Wipe the poly onto a small area of the surface.

After a few moments, use a dry rag to wipe the poly off of the area. Then continue wiping on the rest of the surface.

Use a clean, dry rag to wipe the poly off. This seems pointless, I know. But in fact, you’re not wiping off all of the poly. A thin layer will be left on the surface of the project and will leave you with a perfectly smooth end result. Let it dry and voila! If you’ve done everything correctly, your surface should be glass smooth and gorgeous!

So Many Projects Going At Once, You Don’t Know What To Do Next??
Free Printable Project Planner Pages
Download These Free Printable DIY Project Planner Pages & Get Organized!
Perfectly Applying Polyurethane Pin
Pin it!

Water-Based Polyurethane Application – What You’ll Need

Applying Polyurethane Perfectly- Foolproof Method for Water and Oil-Based Polyurethane Application 10
$ 0.00
$ 19.99
ZAR Semi-Gloss Clear Water Based Polyurethane 1 qt.
3M 05111110144 Sandpaper - Between Coat Finishing Pads
3M 05111110144 Sandpaper – Between Coat Finishing Pads – $1.65

from: Hardware World

Water + Metal = Rust. Therefore water-based polyurethane and steel wool don’t mix. These between coat finishing pads work great for removing any dust nibs or rough spots after your water-based polyurethane coat has dried.

Applying Polyurethane Perfectly- Foolproof Method for Water and Oil-Based Polyurethane Application 11
$ 0.00
$ 22.97
UGL 4 in. Drylok Synthetic Bristle Brush (2-Pack)

If your piece has been stained or painted with an oil-based product, be sure to allow for proper cure time before beginning your water-based polyurethane application.

A good 3 days should be sufficient in the correct environment. The longer you wait, the better.

Applying water-based poly over oil-based stain or paint is possible, but if you don’t wait long enough between the two, your water-based poly may end up beading up when you apply it, and not adhere to the surface properly.

If you touch your stained surface and it still feels oily, it isn’t fully cured. If you’ve waited 2-3 days and the surface is still oily, try wiping it down with mineral spirits. Any stain that hasn’t cured will come off on your rag, leaving only the cured stain, and you’ll be good to go. (If after 2-3 days in the right conditions it hasn’t cured, there was probably too much stain applied from the beginning.)

Related: How To Stain Wood Furniture – Your Questions Answered.

Applying Water-Based Polyurethane Perfectly – Step by Step

I have yet to make videos for water-based polyurethane application, but will be updating this post with them very soon!

The best advice I can give you for applying water-based polyurethane perfectly is to just get it on, and leave it alone.

It will look very messy when you put it on, but water-based poly has an amazing ability to level itself out and dry smooth. That is, only if you let it.

The more brushing you do, the messier it will come out in the end. It’s a tough skill to master, but once you do, it’s a cinch to apply perfectly!

First off, wipe your entire piece down with distilled water to remove any sanding dust and raise the wood grain.

Water-based products raise the grain on wood, which will make it impossible to get a completely smooth surface with the polyurethane. So we want to raise the grain before applying the poly, and sand it back to smooth. Then when we apply the poly, the grain won’t raise and create an uneven surface.

You can use a paintbrush, spray bottle, or wet cloth to wet your surface evenly. You should see some sort of darkening to the wood when you add the water.

Once it has lightened back up completely, you’ll know it’s dry. (Usually 30 minutes or so.) You should be able to feel the raised grain after wetting it.

Using at least 220 grit sandpaper or higher, lightly sand the raised grain back down.

You want to be very light-handed here. 1 or 2 passes over the entire surface tops. You don’t want to sand the actual wood itself, just the grain. If you sand into the wood again you may need to repeat the entire grain raising process. Try using a used piece of sandpaper just to be safe.

There shouldn’t be much dust from doing this, but be sure to wipe down the surface again afterwards.

Open and stir the water-based polyurethane slowly making sure to lift any settlement from the bottom of the can.

Do not shake water-based polyurethane or you’ll cause lots of bubbles! You can pour the poly into a plastic tub to be sure settlement rises to the top as well.

Dip your synthetic paint brush into the poly coating about 3/4 of the bristles, and let hang over the container for a moment to drip excess off.

Don’t scrape the edge of the can or container with your brush. Water-based poly dries very quickly, and can leave hardened poly along the edges of your can. If you scrape your brush against it it will pick those little hard pieces up and you’ll end up with them in your finish.

Unlike oil-based polyurethane, you want to move quickly when applying water-based poly to your surface. Go from one end to the other working with the grain of the wood.

Keep a wet edge, meaning your next stroke should overlap about 1/2″ of the first stroke and so on. But otherwise, don’t go back over the poly once it’s on your surface.

It’s tough to do I know! It won’t look great when you apply your first coat, but it will even out.

Apply a thin coat to the entire surface quickly, and then leave it for 2 hours.

If you think you missed a spot, get it next time. You’ll do more harm than good if you try to apply more on top of already drying poly.

After 2 hours, sand down the poly with 220 grit sandpaper, or a between coat finishing pad, until smooth.

As I said, water-based polyurethane is self-leveling, so you shouldn’t have too many brush marks if you applied it as I said. Any spots that you did touch after the first strokes will probably have brush marks. So sand those out if there are any. Then remove any sanding dust.

Do not use steel wool to smooth out water-based poly. Steel wool sometimes leaves small metal pieces behind, and you’ll end up with rust spots on your surface. Use a finishing pad instead to remove dust nibs.

Apply 2 more thin coats the same way, sanding between each coat and removing any dust.

3 coats should be sufficient for protection of your piece.

If after 3 coats you’re still having issues with brush marks, try applying a final coat by wiping it on with a rag.

Don’t thin it with anything, adding water to it only makes it dry even faster. Dip your rag into the poly and liberally soak it. Wipe it on the same way you would apply with a brush, in long strokes down the grain of the wood.

I’ve found that using a rag makes it easier for me sometimes to not go back over it and cause more problems. Just wipe down one way and back the other, no overlap necessary.

You’ll find less streaking and marks occur than when you’re brushing it on. It definitely helps for the OCD part of me that just wants to smooth out each stroke!

Use an ultra-fine finishing pad to smooth out the final coat.

3M 048011040288 Scotch-Briteâ„¢  Hand Pad ~ Ultra Fine
3M 048011040288 Scotch-Briteâ„¢ Hand Pad ~ Ultra Fine – $24.16

from: Hardware World

Clean up any dust and Voila! You should have a perfectly smooth water-based polyurethane finish.

Applying Polyurethane Perfectly Water-Based Polyurethane Finish
This Farmhouse Dresser Top has a Perfectly Smooth Water-Based Polyurethane Seal

And that’s all there is to it! I hope that after reading this post, you feel confident in yourself applying polyurethane on whichever project you’re working on!

Remember to pin this post for the next time you’re finishing a project with polyurethane. I know I always need a quick refresher after a few weeks!

And if you have any issues with your polyurethane after it has cured, check out my Repairing Damaged Wood Finishes post for help!

Be sure to sign up for my email list to receive updates on new posts like this!

Until Next Time,

KRay

2 replies on “Applying Polyurethane Perfectly- Foolproof Method for Water and Oil-Based Polyurethane Application

  • Bond Corp

    Such an informative article! All the information provided by you is really very helpful. By using tack cloth you can easily remove small dust particles from the surface and it also gives you smooth paint finishing. Thank you for sharing! Keep posting!

    Reply
    • KRay

      Thanks so much for your comment, glad you enjoyed my post 🙂 I 100% agree tack cloths work wonders when removing dust for applications like these. I’ll be sure to add that to my post!

      Reply
Average
5 Based On 1

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

one × five =